The best blender for ice cream shakes has to do something most blenders struggle with: turn mostly hard-frozen ice cream and very little milk into a thick, spoonable shake without stalling or melting it. That takes either a tamper to push the mix into the blades, or a strong motor with a dedicated frozen program.
Quick answer: the Vitamix 5200 is the best blender for thick ice cream shakes because its tamper lets you blend with almost no liquid. The Ninja BN701 Professional Plus is the best value for family batches, and the NutriBullet Pro 900 is the pick for one shake at a time.
This guide is about extra-thick, ice-cream-heavy shakes. If you mostly make regular milkshakes and fruit smoothies, see our separate guide to the best blenders for milkshakes and smoothies; if you want the classic diner spindle mixer instead of a blender, see the best milkshake makers.
How we chose: we did not test these blenders hands-on. Picks are based on manufacturer specifications, owner feedback and how each design handles thick frozen blends.

Blenders for Ice Cream Shakes Compared
| Model | Power | Capacity | Thick-blend help | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vitamix 5200 | 2 peak HP | 64 oz container | Tamper + variable speed | Thickest shakes |
| Ninja BN701 Professional Plus | 1,400 peak watts | 72 oz pitcher (64 oz max liquid) | Ice Cream and Frozen Drink Auto-iQ programs | Family batches on a budget |
| Blendtec Classic 575 | 1,560 watts | 90 oz WildSide+ jar (36 oz blending) | Preset cycles, 5 speeds | Premium without a tamper |
| NutriBullet Pro 900 | 900 watts | 32 oz and 24 oz cups | Short cup keeps ice cream near blades | Single servings |
| Hamilton Beach Wave Crusher | 700 peak watts | 40 oz glass jar | Wave~Action system, Ice Sabre blades | Lowest cost, softer shakes |
Why Ice Cream Shakes Are Hard on Blenders
A thick shake might be three or four scoops of ice cream to a splash of milk. With so little liquid, the blades carve an air pocket and spin freely while the ice cream sits above them. Adding more milk fixes it but thins the shake. The ways around this are a tamper, a jar shape that keeps pushing food down, or a small container where the ice cream cannot escape the blades.
Heat is the other problem: long blending warms the shake. A powerful motor that finishes in 20 to 40 seconds keeps it colder and thicker. For more technique, read how to thicken a milkshake in a blender.
The 5 Best Blenders for Ice Cream Shakes
1. Vitamix 5200 – Best for the Thickest Shakes
The 5200 comes with a classic tamper, and Vitamix specifically recommends using it for thick blends to keep ingredients moving through the blades. That is exactly what an ice-cream-heavy shake needs: you can push the scoops down with minimal milk instead of thinning the shake to get it moving.
It has a 2-peak-horsepower motor, a 64-ounce container, 10 variable speeds plus High, and a 7-year warranty. Its tall container is less ideal for a single small shake; a two-serving batch works better.
Good fit for: Anyone who wants concrete-thick shakes and will also use the blender for soups, nut butters and smoothies.
Skip it if: You only make one small shake now and then; the price is hard to justify.
2. Ninja BN701 Professional Plus – Best Value
Ninja’s BN701 pairs a 1,400-peak-watt base with a 72-ounce Total Crushing pitcher and three Auto-iQ programs: Smoothie, Frozen Drink and Ice Cream. The timed pulse-and-pause patterns help pull frozen ingredients back into the stacked blades without you stopping to stir.
There is no tamper, so very low-liquid shakes may still need a pause and a scrape. The big pitcher shines for three or four shakes at once.
Good fit for: Families who make several shakes at once and want strong power for the money.
Skip it if: You usually make a single thick shake; the tall pitcher is overkill.
3. Blendtec Classic 575 – Best Premium Without a Tamper
Blendtec takes a different approach: a 1,560-watt motor, blunt wide blades and a WildSide+ jar shaped to keep ingredients circulating. You get preset cycles (Smoothie, Clean, 60-second and 90-second) and five manual speeds.
The 90-ounce jar has a 36-ounce blending capacity, which suits two to four shakes. Without a tamper, the thickest shakes need a little more milk than with the Vitamix.
Good fit for: Buyers who want commercial-style power and one-touch cycles.
Skip it if: You want the absolute thickest result; the Vitamix tamper does that better.
4. NutriBullet Pro 900 – Best for One Shake
A personal blender is a smart choice for single ice cream shakes: the 24-ounce cup keeps the scoops pressed onto the extractor blade, so there is nowhere for an air pocket to form. The Pro 900 has a 900-watt base and comes with 32-ounce and 24-ounce cups plus a to-go lid.
It has one speed and is designed for short blends, so use slightly softened ice cream and do not run it for long periods.
Good fit for: One or two people who want a quick shake in the cup they drink from.
Skip it if: You make shakes for a group or want precise speed control.
5. Hamilton Beach Wave Crusher – Budget Pick
Hamilton Beach’s Wave Crusher uses a Wave~Action system designed to pull the mix down into the Ice Sabre blades, with 700 watts of peak power and a dishwasher-safe 40-ounce glass jar.
At this power level, plan on softer, more sippable shakes: let the ice cream sit out for a few minutes and add a bit more milk.
Good fit for: Occasional shake makers on a tight budget who like a glass jar.
Skip it if: You want truly thick, spoon-standing shakes.
Buying Guide: Choosing a Blender for Ice Cream Shakes
Tamper or container design
A tamper is the single most useful feature for thick shakes. Without one, look for a jar designed to circulate thick mixtures or use a small personal cup.
Power
More power means shorter blend times and colder shakes. Around 1,000 watts or more handles hard ice cream comfortably; under that, soften the ice cream first.
Batch size
Match the container to how many shakes you make. Big pitchers struggle with a single scoop-heavy shake because the ingredients sit below the blade reach; personal cups cannot make four at once.
Cleaning
Ice cream leaves a sticky film. Self-clean cycles (warm water and a drop of soap) and dishwasher-safe parts make daily use easier.
Who Should Not Buy a Blender Just for Shakes?
- You only want classic diner-style shakes: a spindle mixer whips air in and is cheaper.
- You already own a solid full-size blender; technique (softened ice cream, liquid first, short pulses) may be all you need.
- You want soft-serve or frozen desserts more than drinks; a dedicated ice cream maker suits that better.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a blender or a milkshake maker better for ice cream shakes?
A spindle milkshake maker gives a lighter, airy diner shake. A strong blender makes thicker shakes and can blend in cookies, candy and frozen fruit.
How do I keep an ice cream shake thick in a blender?
Use very cold milk, let hard ice cream soften a few minutes, add liquid first, blend in short bursts and use a tamper if you have one.
What ratio of ice cream to milk makes a thick shake?
Start with about three scoops of ice cream to a quarter cup of milk and add a splash at a time only if the blender stalls.
Can a personal blender make ice cream shakes?
Yes. Small cups often handle thick shakes well because the ice cream stays on the blades; just keep blends short.
Final Verdict
For the thickest ice cream shakes, the Vitamix 5200 and its tamper are hard to beat. The Ninja BN701 is the value choice for family batches, the Blendtec Classic 575 is the premium one-touch alternative, the NutriBullet Pro 900 is best for single servings, and the Hamilton Beach Wave Crusher covers occasional, softer shakes on a budget.











